How to Grill Ribs as Succulent and Juicy as the Finest Rib Shack

This post may include affiliate links.

Although we love a juicy burger, a seared steak and even a weeknight chicken cookout, ribs are the ultimate grilled meal. They’re messy, indulgent, delicious and turn an ordinary summer afternoon into a festive occasion.

Grilling ribs might seem intimidating because they require more time over the coals than lots of other meats. Here’s the truth: Because they cook low and slow, they actually have a wider window of perfection than something like, say, a T-bone steak that relies on a savvy sense of timing and temperature. If you take some time to prep ribs correctly and learn where to cook on the grill, they’re easy enough even for beginners. (We have recipes for pitmasters right this way.)

Let’s start by covering some basics.

Four Secrets to Grilling the Best Ribs

1. Know the different types of ribs

Don’t just grab a pack of ribs at the store and run. Different types of ribs have different flavor and texture and, thus, cooking techniques. Here are the three most common types of ribs:

Baby back ribs are the most common and easiest to find. They are smaller, meatier and leaner than other types. (We grill baby back ribs in this how-to.)

Spareribs are larger with flat bones. They have more connective tissues, so after a long cooking time, they’ll get very tender.

St. Louis-style ribs are spareribs with the rib tips removed. They have a more uniform, rectangular shape than the other types. They’re trickier to cook, so you might want to start experimenting with baby backs or spareribs first.

2. Enhance flavor by thinking ahead

Some people only marinade their ribs. Some people only spice rub. We like to do both. Marinading adds layers of flavor that penetrate deep into the meat, thanks to a long overnight soak. The spice rub adds flavor to the surface of the meat. When the grill sears the ribs, the spicy, crackling exterior of the meat makes a delicious contrast to the tender, succulent meat inside.

Seasoning your meat in advance gives the meat time to take on the flavors. This means you’ll serve up a meal that’s already delicious, even if you don’t add salt or barbecue sauce at the end. (OK, we’d never skip the sauce, but it’s nice to use the sauce as a highlight rather than as a coverup for bland food.)

3. Cook low and slow

Here’s the real secret to good ribs. Cook them over indirect flames, and give them time. This lets the connective tissue melt away, leaving you with perfectly tender, toothsome ribs. If you cook them too quickly, over high heat, the meat can turn out chewy and tough. Like Mom always said, good things take time. (Here are some of our favorite recipes from moms.)

4. Know the right way to test for doneness

We’ve all heard the old saying: Ribs should “fall off the bone.” It’s printed in virtually every laminated menu in every rib joint in the country.

Should your ribs really fall off the bone? Our Test Kitchen experts say no.

We suspect the phrase was coined as a catchy way of saying the ribs are tender. We can all agree that chewy ribs are no fun, but if the meat is literally falling off the bones, then the ribs are overcooked and might be dry.

What to look for instead: The meat should be fork tender (if you pierce it with a fork, it’ll glide right through). Twist an individual rib, and it should give easily. That’s that: They’re done.

How to Grill Baby Back Ribs

You’ll need:

For the marinade:

3/4 cup chicken broth

3/4 cup soy sauce

1 cup sugar, divided

6 tablespoons cider vinegar

6 tablespoons olive oil

3 garlic cloves, minced

For the meat:

2 racks baby-rack ribs (about 4-1/2 pounds)

For the spice rub:

2 teaspoons salt

1 tablespoon paprika

1/2 teaspoon chili powder

1/2 teaspoon pepper

1/4 teaspoon garlic powder

Dash cayenne pepper

For serving:

Barbecue sauce, optional

Step 1: Prep the meat

Most store-bought ribs have what’s known as silverskin, a membrane over the underside of the ribs. Sometimes, if you’re lucky, your butcher will remove it for you. Otherwise, you need to remove it before you cook. Don’t panic, it’s simple to do.

Insert a knife between the membrane and the meat at one end of the ribs. Be careful not to pierce the membrane. Work your fingers under the skin to loosen it. Now you’re going to tug it off. Wrap a paper towel around your hand so you can get a good grip. Gently but firmly, pull off the silverskin. It should peel off quite cleanly.

Step 2: Make the marinade

Pork is tasty as is, but marinading the meat enhances that flavor. It adds a deep savoriness that makes the meat more satisfying and delicious (meaning you won’t need to douse it in barbecue sauce, unless that’s your thing).

Making a marinade is easy. It’s really just stirring together a variety of liquids and spices and letting the meat soak in them overnight. For this recipe, combine the broth, soy sauce, ½ cup sugar, vinegar, olive oil and garlic in a bowl or measuring cup with a pour spout. Place the ribs in a shallow baking dish (we like our trusty 13×9). Pour two-thirds of the marinade over the meat. Turn to coat both sides, then refrigerate overnight. Turn the meat occasionally, to ensure that the meat is marinading evenly. (No need to get out of bed to do this. Just turn at night just before bedtime and turn again in the morning.)

Don’t toss that remaining marinade. Cover and refrigerate it. You’ll use it while you’re grilling.

Step 3: Treat the meat to a spice rub

Trust us: You want to add the spice rub. Like making the marinade, it’s simple to prep, just tossing some ingredients together in a bowl. Here, we use the remaining ½ cup sugar, plus salt and seasonings.

Take the ribs out of the fridge. Drain and discard the marinade from the 13×9. Pat the ribs dry (this helps the spice rub stick). Rub the spice mixture over all sides of the ribs, patting with your fingertips to encourage it to adhere.

Step 4: Grill

Ribs should be cooked low and slow. For most of the cooking, the ribs stay over indirect heat. If you’re cooking over a too-hot grill, the meat will dry out.

First, oil the grill. (Have a charcoal grill like we do? Use these tips to make it gas-grill easy.)

Place the ribs right on the grill, using tongs to maneuver them into place. Grill, covered, over indirect medium heat for 30 minutes on each side.

After the first hour, move the ribs to direct medium heat and cook 20-40 minutes longer, or until the pork is tender (more on this in a minute).

Occasionally, turn and baste with the reserved marinade (or barbecue sauce, if you prefer).

Test Kitchen tip: Once you start to baste with the sauce, keep a watchful eye on it in case the sugars start to caramelize (brown) quickly. You’d hate to burn the ribs now after all your preparations up to this point. This is why we wait to baste until the end of the cooking time.

Step 5: Test for doneness

As we discussed above, you don’t want ribs to fall off the bone. Start testing for doneness once the meat begins to pull away from the ends of the bones. This visual cue means it’s time to test. Pierce the meat with a fork. The tines should glide through easily. You also can twist a rib bone a little bit; you should feel it give easily but not fall apart from the meat. (If the meat falls off the bone, your ribs are overcooked. Remove from heat right away and make sure to have sauce at the table in case they’re a bit dry. Don’t beat yourself up! Next time, remember to check earlier.)

Step 6: Serve

By now, you’ve certainly built up an appetite. To serve the ribs, you’ll want to split them up into manageable portions. Using a sharp chef’s knife, carefully cut them into two-bone sections. Make the cuts as close to the bone as possible so there’s a lot of meat on each one. Serve with more barbecue sauce, corn on the cob, big glasses of lemonade and a fistful of napkins for everyone.

Try out these other recipes for the perfect ribs:

Top 10 Recipes for Grilling Ribs 

60 Crowd-Pleasing, Rib-Sticking, Classic Midwestern Slow Cooker Recipes 

25 Unbelievably Tender Slow Cooker Ribs

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.